‘Sex and the City’: Carrie and Aidan’s Relationship in Season 4 Is the Most Realistic in the Show


Carrie Bradshaw, reporter at Feis and the City, on many relationships during the show’s six-season run. She had only two great loves, however. Carrie’s relationships with Mr. Big and Aidan Shaw eventually came to an end and the series. While she eventually ended up with Mr. Big, it can be said that the failed relationship of Aidan was the most rational of her relationships.

Season 3 Aidan was too perfect, some fans argue

Carrie and Aidan met in his furniture store and quickly started going back in season 3 of Feis and the City. Carrie was fresh from another round of heartbreak courtesy of Mr. Big. Aidan seemed to tick every box Carrie could ask for, and the pair were happy, for at least a few minutes.

Sarah Jessica Parker as Carrie Bradshaw and John Corbett as Aidan Shaw sit on Carrie’s front steps
Sarah Jessica Parker as Carrie Bradshaw and John Corbett as Aidan Shaw | Very important photos / journalists

LOVE: ‘Sex and the City’: Fans notice that Aidan Shaw was seeing a rapid move forward

When Mr. Big returned to his life, Carrie started it. The romance, to which she told Aidan about the morning of Charlotte’s marriage to Trey McDougal, ended Carrie and Aidan’s relationship, and Mr. Big and Natasha’s marriage. While fans accepted that this was the last thing they saw of Aidan, they were wrong. The Aidan with whom they reconnected again the following year was very different from the man in whom they were originally introduced, however.

Aidan’s return in season 4 brought a tough and much calmer companion

By the time Carrie and Aidan reunited in season 4, Mr. Big’s marriage to Natasha was officially over. In an desperate attempt to recapture what she once had with Aidan, Carrie brought him back into a relationship. He willingly went with him.

Carrie Bradshaw and Mr Big appear together in 'Sex and the City'
Sarah Jessica Parker as Carrie Bradshaw and Chris Noth as Mr. Big | Very important photos / journalists

LOVE: ‘Sex and the City’: What was Carrie Bradshaw ‘s worst quality?

Although Carrie was the only person she was when she first met Aidan, it was very different. The once sweet and hospitable Aidan was a bit harsh and emotionally unavailable. He was also much more relaxed about Carrie and very insecure. Even his marriage proposal was about his insecurity rather than his love for the woman he saw.

Carrie and Aidan’s season 4 relationship is the most realistic portrayal of a troubled relationship

Aidan and Carrie were not together. To some fans, that was a shame. If you think about it, though, the end of the relationship is the most realistic picture of lost love in the series. Deception certainly does not make a bad impression for a relationship, however Psychology today warns that accountability and setting boundaries is essential for a couple to overcome infidelity.

John Corbett and Sarah Jessica Parker attend the premiere of season 3 of 'Sex and the City'
John Corbett and Sarah Jessica Parker Jim Smeal / Ron Galella Collection via Getty Images

LOVE: ‘Sex and the City’: One fan points out just how poisonous Aidan Shaw was

Carrie and Aidan never set boundaries, and Carrie was never responsible for what she did once Aidan agreed to take her back. Aidan did not communicate as he felt at any particular time, and as a result, their relationship was wrong. The end of the relationship was a true picture of what happens when disobedience occurs, but the painful feelings are never talked about.